Law Offices of Alice A. Salvo Logo

What Constitutes Undue Influence?

12/14/2022 | Heirs & Beneficiaries

If you fear that your elderly, ill or disabled parent in California is developing too much reliance on a caregiver, you may wish to take preventative measures to ensure that your parent does not change the will while under this person’s undue influence. As explained by a state bar association at its recent meeting, undue influence occurs when one individual assumes a power position over another individual and misuses that power to overcome the victim’s free will and substitute his/her own will.

Your parent must “be of sound mind” to make a valid last will and testament. This means the parent must have the following knowledge and capabilities:

  • The parent must realize the nature and extent of his/her property and assets.
  • The parent must realize and remember who the law expects him/her to name as heirs, such as a spouse, children, grandchildren, etc.
  • The parent must realize that (s)he is making his/her last will and testament.
  • The parent must not be under any delusions or influences that could cause him/her to make unusual, unexpected or “surprise” bequests, particularly those having a large value.

Undue influence indications

Unfortunately, an overly assertive caregiver is the classic example of someone who exerts undue influence over his/her patient so that the patient will leave him/her a substantial bequest when (s)he dies. If you suspect that your parent’s caregiver fits this description, be on the lookout for the following red flags:

  • The caregiver tries to isolate your parent from you and the rest of the family.
  • The caregiver tries to discourage you and other family members from visiting your parent.
  • The caregiver insists on staying in the room and joining in the conversation when you or other family members are at your parent’s house.
  • The caregiver screens your parent’s phone calls
  • The caregiver helps your parent pay bills and manage his/her finances even though such things are not part of the duties for which (s)he was hired.
  • The caregiver administers and therefore controls the medications your parent receives.

If these or other red flags convince you that your parent’s caregiver is unduly influencing him/her, you should attempt to persuade your parent to fire him/her. If the parent refuses to be fire the caregiver, do your best to thwart the caregiver’s attempt to isolate your parent. Also be sure to keep reassuring your parent that you and the rest of the family loves, values and wants the best for him/her. If the situation continues to deteriorate, explore the possibility of intervening.

If you have concerns, call the Law Office of Alice A. Salvo for a free initial consultation.